Category Archives Judge Limbaugh

Judge Limbaugh's analysis in City of O'Fallon v. Centurylink, Inc., 2013 WL 1036514 (E.D. Mo., March 14, 2013), is interesting in two respects. First, it's interesting because the Court did not simply decline to exercise its jurisdiction as Judge Fleissig did in City of Maryland Heights v. Trafcone Wireless, Inc., 2013 WL 791866 (E.D. Mo., March 4, 2013), a similar class action composed of plaintiff municipalities seeking to recover business license taxes from defendant providers of telephone services. It's also interesting for its thorough discussion of what exactly constitutes a "significant defendant" for purposes of applying CAFA's Local Controversy Exception. This analysis was a bit of overkill because the Court had already determined that the removing defendants had failed to meet their burden of establishing both the requisite amount in controversy (defendants had pleaded only $4.2 million in controversy in their Notice of Removal and had inexplicably ignored attorneys' fees…

The recent order in Burkeen v. New Madrid Ambulance Dist., 2013 WL 880079 (E.D. Mo., March 8, 2013) is relatively unremarkable (the defendant didn't really contest preliminary certification), but potentially useful in how it addresses some mechanical aspects of FLSA notice. In this putative FLSA action brought on behalf of EMTs seeking overtime pay, the defendant challenged the scope of employee information it was required to hand over to class counsel, the facilitation of class notice, and the contents of class notice. Judge Limbaugh ruled that: The defendant must hand over putative class members' names, addresses, phone numbers and e mail addresses (useful for contacting employees who have moved), and dates of employment, but not their locations of employment; The defendant must post class notice in break rooms, but need not include class notice in pay stubs (because other forms of contact were adequate); Class notice need not include a…

Close